Way back in 2005 a little jukebox musical first premiered on Broadway telling the story of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons called Jersey Boys. This musical became a huge critical and financial success going on to win 4 Tony Awards and have over 4000 performances. Despite becoming a phenomenon it somehow eluded me and I had never seen it until this Friday with Pioneer Theatre Company’s new production. While I don’t have anything to compare the it to I left feeling energized and entertained, and I can see why it sets the standard for biographical jukebox musicals.

Jersey Boys has music by Bob Gaudio (the Bob from the band) and Lyrics by Bob Crewe. Of course it features the many hits from the The Four Seasons like “Big Girls Don’t Cry,” “Sherry,” and “Can’t Take My Eyes Off of You” which are all a lot of fun to hear performed on stage; however, the real standout of the show is the book by Marshall Brickman and Rick Elice. The problem a lot of biographic jukebox musicals have is they are so predictable in their rags-to-riches formula and then take themselves far too seriously. Jersey Boys sets itself apart from these copycats by being consistently funny and endearing throughout.

At PTC our 4 leads seem to understand this strength of the show and lean into the humor creating a believable chemistry as a group that makes us invested in what is happening to them. While they are all more convincing as older versions of the characters in act 2 they delivered the dialogue with terrific comic timing and the charm someone like a rockstar should have. Trevor James pulls off the falsetto needed for Frankie Valli but my favorite is Brent Thiessen as Nick.

I think Nick works the best because his section of the story is the most clearly defined. That’s one thing director Karen Azenberg could have emphasized more is making more obvious who is narrating each of the 4 acts. Nevertheless, they are all great in their roles, and like I said, the comedic elements kept it from feeling tired and cliched.

The technical elements of Jersey Boys at PTC is kept streamlined and simple with most of the backgrounds being stages, brick walls or a warehouse. The costumes are mostly various suits that are swapped in and out of quickly, but I wouldn’t have wanted anything more because the simplicity kept me focused on the actors on stage. The ensemble is also small but capable as they swap in and out of various roles. I particularly liked Timothy Aaron Cooper as ‘Joe Pesci and others’ who skillfully brings out the humor to any scene he is in.

The orchestra conducted by Phil Reno is always a standout at PTC, and they do an excellent job with these classic songs. There are times when the actors on stage are more convincing in “playing” the instruments than others but the actual orchestra is fantastic.

Adam Enrique Hollick and Daxton Bloomquist are also very strong as Tommy and Bob respectively although it feels like Tommy should have been far more grateful for Frankie literally saving him from prison than he was. Bloomquist did a good job capturing Bob’s subtle awkwardness so when he says he wants to stop performing in the band and just produce and write it isn’t a huge surprise.

Evidently down at Tuacahn they did a version of Jersey Boys with cleaned up language. While I have only seen this I prefer the more mature version as it feels authentic to the characters.

In the end, I’m grateful to Pioneer Theatre Company for giving me a terrific first time experience with Jersey Boys. The talented cast brought Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons to life with humor, humanity and terrific singing. You won’t want to take your eyes off of the stage! Jersey Boys is playing through Sept 28th and tickets can be purchased here.

Also the humor in this show makes it abundantly clear why the Clint Eastwood directed film adaptation failed so badly…

 If you’d like me to review more theatre and appreciate what I do please check out the patreon here. You will find the patreon has many benefits including watch alongs with writers and actors of TV and films and more. Please take a look.