Most of the time as a theatregoer and critic I look at a piece through a lens of entertainment. If I’m watching a musical I ask myself how engaged I was with the music and dance elements? If it’s a straight play how engrossed am I with the story and performances? However, there are times when an experience at a theatre takes on more of an educational role helping us to engage with historical events and social issues on a more visceral and artistic level. Such is the experience at the recent performance of 4/20/99: A Story of Columbine at the Regent Black Box at the Eccles Theater in Salt Lake. It is a grueling experience but powerful and worth experiencing and remembering a violent day of American history.

In this play writer and director Autumn Marie Cazier takes us to the days before the Columbine High School Massacre as perpetrated by teens Dylan Klebold and Eric Harris. Evidently these 2 made the Columbine Tapes before their decision to stage a mass shooting at their high school and which much of their dialogue in the play is based off of. These events are particularly poignant to me because I graduated from high school in 1999 (I was attending community college for my senior year) so I was the same age as the Klebold and Harris and vividly remember seeing the events play out on the news.

The most impressive aspect of 4/20/99 is the performances from the mostly young cast. Ryan Munsey and Andrew Myers are realistically chilling as Klebold and Harris. The way they talk about blowing up their classmates as some kind of dare in a movie (Natural Born Killers is a particular favorite) is chilling and unforgettable. Anell Gathercole is also excellent a Robyn Anderson who is making understandable decisions for a simple teenage girl not realizing they will have disastrous consequences. We as the audience know what horrible mistakes she’s naively making and can only watch in horror.

The actual events of the massacre play out in Act 2 and Cazier uses sound (sound technician Ian Bengyzen) to take you to the high school and that moment as well as making sure the emphasis is on the victims with photos and words in memoriam for each of them. For the most part these scenes are played out without much artistic license with one exception. In a portion of the tapes Dylan talks about a halcyon girl who will welcome him into the afterlife. At one point he dances with this girl and because everything else is so grounded and real I found it confusing and strange. It just didn’t fit tonally with the rest of the play in my opinion.

I also worry the play loses some of its efficacy when it becomes too much of a trauma dump. Perhaps such issue-oriented violent plays would be better as one acts or smaller skits? It’s a lot to take in such anger and hatred especially from teens. It would also be nice if such performances were more action-oriented. What I mean by that is we as the audience are put through a traumatic experience and surely the creators must have something specific they want us to do with that trauma? They present a bunch of statistics for violent crime but what’s their hopeful solution? A lot of things have been attempted to help with gun crime over the years but to no avail. A specific call to action could help transform the play from something upsetting to empowering.

That said, if you get a chance to see 4/20/99: A Story of Columbine I recommend it. It’s brutal but also a searing and extremely well acted reminder of what two bitter hearts can do to others if left unchecked. The human heart is truly capable of some horrible actions and that is terrifying and humbling. The play’s run has finished at the Regent but you can find out more about future productions here.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.