As a film and theatre critic I think it is valuable to push myself out of my comfort zone. While it is good for longevity to find a niche and specialize in content as I have done with romantic comedies and holiday material I want to continually grow and expand my tastes each day. This is why when given the opportunity to see Drag: The Musical during my last New York trip I jumped at the chance. In many ways I am not the target demographic for this show but I think an outsider perspective can often have value and be informative to my readers who may be interested in seeing the play or film but also in allowing their vision of me as a human and critic to not be so narrow and limited. Anyway, I was given the opportunity to see Drag: The Musical at the New World Stages, an Off Broadway theatre and I left having had a good time with a surprisingly sweet and endearing production.

My main context for saying I am not the target demographic for this show is I am basically unfamiliar with the drag movement and the fandom associated with show’s like RuPaul’s Drag Race. I am not morally opposed to it it’s just not something I have watched or become informed on. Those that are familiar with the scene will find much to be excited for in the cast and story of Drag: The Musical. The audience cheered when certain performers appeared so I only assume they have a following and will be enjoyable for their fans to see perform live.

The story (the book, music, and lyrics were all collaboratively written by Tomas Costanza, Justin Andrew Honard, and Ashley Gordon) is basic but it does the job to provide setpieces for the queens to sing, dance and even give some heart that I didn’t expect from a campy show like this. The setup is Kitty Galloway (Alaska Thunderfuck) and Alexis Gillmore (Nick Adams) are feuding exes who run opposing clubs near each other. Unbeknownst to both they are both facing financial struggles and Alexis’ straight brother Tom comes in to help the Fish Tank from going under (Kitty runs the fancier but equally struggling Cat House.)

When I saw it Tom was played by Joey McIntyre, which as an 80s girl was a lot of fun to see. The entire cast had a nice chemistry together even when they were supposed to be feuding with each other. J. Elaine Marcos delivers the lion-share of the laughs playing 3 roles- an IRS agent, a sleezy lawyer, and a difficult landlady. Eddie Korbich plays a character known as Drunk Jerry that was less effective in delivering the laughs but his character is a bridge between both clubs the story relies upon.

Director Spencer Liff keeps the action moving from gag to sentimental moment; however, I do think the show is long for not having an intermission and my friend had to leave midway through to use the bathroom and then struggled to find her seat again. In addition, while I found it to be amusing I wasn’t uproariously laughing like I was for another show I saw at New World Stages as a patron Dracula: A Comedy of Terrors or for The Play that Goes Wrong which is still playing there (although I haven’t seen it there but other places.) Surprisingly I almost find it to be a more satisfying piece of good-natured sentimentality than a laugh-out-loud comedy. At its core Drag: The Musical is about family and of course love and acceptance, which is always a message worthy of sharing.

The production elements of the show are definitely worthy of praise. Jason Sherwood’s set manages to tell the stories of both clubs while giving plenty of space for laughs to occur. The costumes by Marco Marco are as big and over-the-top as fans will hope for and the lighting by Adam Honoré is perfect in capturing that club atmosphere needed for the story.

Both Alaska and Adams are a lot of fun in their roles with Alaska getting the more dishy of the leads but particularly Adams’ interactions with young Yair Keydar playing nephew Brendan are very warm and endearing. Like I said, I think many will be surprised how sweet and family-oriented a show like Drag: the Musical is. It’s certainly not what I was expecting.

If you are in the fandom I definitely recommend finding your way to New World Stages and seeing Drag: The Musical and even if you’re not give it a shot. It just might surprise you! Adam Pascal is now playing the role of Tom, which would be a lot of fun to see. You can find more information and get tickets here.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.