As a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and returned missionary I of course have heard much about the Broadway musical The Book of Mormon. I had heard some of the songs and that it is super raunchy, but I had never had the opportunity to see it until last week. Now having seen it my response is a decided ‘meh.’ I am sure there are some who will dismiss this reaction as a biased member who can’t take a joke. While there might be some of that (we can’t completely separate our lives from our responses to theatre), I honestly I found the whole thing to be quite bland and wish it had gone harder on the unique aspects of my faith.

In 2003 the creators of The Book of Mormon musical, Trey Parker and Matt Stone (with Robert Lopez) did an episode of South Park on Mormonism that in my opinion was a lot more biting and funny than anything we get here. Most of the jokes in this musical are jokes that could be made about any Christians. In fact, it sometimes felt like they wanted to do a show about evangelicals but that’s not financially viable so put a Mormon skin over it and you’re good.

The biggest example of this is the song “Spooky Mormon Hell Dream.” This song made no sense as Mormons don’t believe in Hell. We certainly don’t believe in a Hell with horns and a devil and damnation. In fact, Mormons believe almost everyone will get some kind of glory in the afterlife with most people who lead good and honest lives getting a pretty high degree of glory. You know who does believe in Hell with a devil with horns? Evangelicals.

It also goes without saying that most of what they show about missionary work is completely ridiculous. Missionaries don’t get assigned a companion for their entire mission out of the MTC. They don’t just make up what to teach on their own. They don’t get to request a transfer to another mission because they don’t like it. The list goes on. None of this would matter if I was laughing but like I said most of the jokes felt bland and expected so I wasn’t laughing.

It also doesn’t help with laughs that the portrayal of the Ugandan people is bizarre and dehumanizing. I understand it’s an over-the-top comedy but humor usually comes from painting a contrast. Something stupid with something smart. Something stable with something high strung etc. Here everyone but maybe Elder Price is a simpleton so it feels pretty cringe-worthy. None of that would matter if I was laughing, (I always say funny saves all) but I wasn’t so it just made me uncomfortable.

The highlights of the musical are the sharp “Turn it Off” which brings the biting satire to the Church I was looking for, and Elder Price singing “I Believe.” The talent is all good in the tour with Sam McLellan as Elder Price and Diego Enrico as Elder Cunningham. The choreography throughout (choreography by Jennifer Werner with original choreography by Casey Nicholaw) is bouncy and energetic and the other technical aspects are all excellent.

It goes without saying that a show like The Book of Mormon has lots to offend including frequent uses of profanity, references to raping babies and other vulgarity. If that doesn’t sound like your thing than I would avoid it. If that doesn’t bother you I can’t say I’d recommend it either but it is a musical enjoyed by millions so what do I know? It is playing at Eccles until January 26th and you can purchase a ticket here.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.