Pretty much everyone knows at this point that I love and adore the musical Daddy Long Legs. I enjoy it so much I’ve seen it 11 times since the pandemic including seeing it 5 times just this year. I love the build up of the romance between Jerusha and Jervis and how they both grow as people through the show, and the songs are musical perfection. With this love for the material, I knew I wanted to get down to see St George Musical Theatre’s production, and it did not disappoint. I was able to see all 4 performers (they alternated the roles during the run) and they all did a wonderful job. It was worth the trip!

First up on Friday night, I saw Heather Oram as Jerusha and Tim Merkley as Jervis. Then, the next day I saw Mattea Denney and Pierce Robison in those roles. The production is directed by Edwina Jones, and she keeps things simple and lets her cast shine. I do love when the directors of this musical allow for some kind of connection between the 2 like a mailbox or a bookcase where they set the letters down. They didn’t do anything like that here, but it’s fine without it, too.

The only major feedback I’d give is the directors have to be very careful in the portrayal of Jervis. The text makes it clear that he is a young man, which helps excuse his many weaknesses. That said, leaning into the jealousy (saying things like ‘over my dead body’), while funny, makes the character seem more controlling and less likable. It’s a nuance thing, but I would advise productions to be as understated in those scenes as possible and show the right amount of remorse with “I’m a Beast” and “Charity.”

I enjoyed both of the couples and was impressed with the chemistry they were able to build, particularly Denney and Robison. With the show being epistolary, it could be dry if that connection between them wasn’t as well done and believable. This performance was at the Main St Performing Arts Campus, and this is a beautiful stage and building. I didn’t mind seeing 2 shows there one bit.

Unfortunately, the run of Daddy Long Legs at SGMT has finished, but I encourage any readers to see this wonderful show if you have the chance. It will help you believe in love and the power of human connection like never before. Make sure you check out A Christmas Story at SGMT while you have the chance. Tickets can be purchased here.

Daddy Long Legs has music and lyrics by Paul Gordon with a book by John Caird based on the novel by Jean Webster. It premiered Off-Broadway in 2015.

Make sure to check out my interview with Paul Gordon

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks like bonus episodes, patron polls and monthly Q&As with actors, directors and writers. Please take a look here.