It might seem like an odd comparison but I feel the same way about the national tour of Hadestown that is currently at the Eccles downtown as I did about Les Miserables national tour last year. Both have very strong material (obviously) that is executed in the most meh way possible. If you see Hadestown you’ll probably have a good time because the music, lyrics and book are great but not from the bland uninspired choices of this production. You can honestly find better executed stagings at the myriads of high schools doing the Hadestown Teen Edition all over the state of Utah.

The biggest problem with the production is one of scope. Everything feels small and simple. This is a show that relies a lot on spectacle. The lights alone on the Broadway show are stunning and bold and that’s not the case here. I know there are only 5 workers on Broadway but the more intimate staging there makes it still feel grand where at the large Eccles theater the afterlife looked rather sparse. Also the director Keenan Tyler Oliphant slows down certain segments like “Why We Build the Wall” so that my mind began to wander about the smallness of the cast.

The musicians are on the stage in the tradition of Hadestown, but they don’t blend as well as I would like. The brass really sticks out in sections as did the violins which I’ve never noticed in this show before. They really go for a Mardi Gras New Orleans feel which I get but seems a little celebratory in tone for the events of Hadestown. It is also strange the way they have Persephone open act 2 with “Our Lady of the Underground” like she is a lounge singer at a club. I know she’s supposed to be boozy but it is handled like a cabaret performance not a key moment in the story.

My favorite acting of the night is Nickolaus Colón as Hades. He makes those low notes feel effortless, and I love his slick soulful interpretation of “Hey Little Songbird.” Even though the Fates do not harmonize as well as I’d like I still loved the “Epic” songs especially “Epic III” which is peak musical theatre if you ask me.

I also can’t help but gasp when Orpheus (Jose Contreras) turns around at the end but the way they have it staged is so odd with lights and fog that made it impossible to see Eurydice (Hawa Kamara) behind him. It is like it all of the sudden became a rock concert with strobe lights instead of a journey to the afterlife. It reminded me of the ending of Beetlejuice: The Musical and that’s not at all what I want out of Hadestown.

It might seem like I am being too tough on this production. It is after all still Hadestown and most people who go see it will still enjoy it. However, the tickets are expensive and if I have had better experiences at the local high schools than that’s a problem. I’m sure I will be in the minority because the material is still very strong but when I see a professional production (even non-equity) I expect better than high schools. I even thought some of the costume choices particularly for Persephone were odd. Unfortunately, I’d recommend saving your money on this one and supporting a local high school production instead. Hopebox is putting it on next month and I bet it will be incredible and for a good cause. The Hadestown national tour is playing at the Eccles through 3/29 and tickets can be purchased here.

Hadestown has music, lyrics and a book by Anaïs Mitchell based on the greek myth Orpheus and Eurydice. It first premiered on Broadway in 2019 and it is still currently playing. I saw it in 2021.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks like bonus episodes, patron polls and monthly Q&As with actors, directors and writers. Please take a look here.