Anyone who knows me and knows my theatre tastes knows I am a sucker for anything that feels unexpected and immersive. For example, I love when a company takes a space not intended for theatre and turns it into a performance space. I also love being surrounded by movement and action. Such is the cool experience being offered this weekend by Millcreek Community Theatre and their new production of 12 Angry Jurors. You wouldn’t believe it but the play is being put on at Millcreek City Hall in an office room set up as a mini-theater with lighting and seats on all 4 sides (this is a change from previous shows seen in this space, which I enjoyed very much. The only downside is it might not work for someone sensitive to bright lights but I got used to it and enjoyed the immersion. Anyway, you’d never guess walking into city hall office space you’d be treated to such a wonderful play but that’s what you get .

To begin with it’s very smart of MCT to pick 12 Angry Jurors for this type of experience. It not only is a straight play but it all takes place in one room so there’s no need to worry about set changes or other challenges different shows might bring up (their last show was Annie and it was fun but not as successful as this play.) I know a lot of companies are scared to put on straight plays but if they are well crafted like 12 Angry Jurors I really think they make a lot of sense.

Most will know the story of this play from the feature film with Henry Fonda. Indeed, 12 Angry Men is one of the finest closed-door films ever made. Sidney Lumet does such a brilliant job with that film creating atmosphere and tone and the legendary character actors are allowed to dive into their meaty roles with Lee J Cobb and Ed Begley as the racists jurors 3 and 10 respectively. In this adaptation they have made it 12 Angry Jurors and they have 6 females and 6 males making up our jury with Michael Hansen and Shauna Brand as 3 and 10 (these are the 2 most bombastic and controversial of the jurors so they stand out the most.) They are both excellent in their roles as is the entire cast. One would never expect to get such high caliber performances walking up to an office space at city hall! Unbelievable!

Despite the gender swaps director Jax Jessop has kept the events of the play in the 1950s and all of the actors have period appropriate costumes (costume design Eleanor Boam) and most of them are even smoking, which is a detail I don’t expect to see in local community theater. It honestly was about as close to Mad Men meets Utah as one could achieve in this space. I also like the added detail of having an actor, Connor Kraus, playing the accused watching what is happening as men and women debate his life. Again, it helped add to the immersive experience of the night.

Kiana Dipko is good with the less showy role as Juror 8 (the Henry Fonda role if you’ve seen the movie.) It’s important that you don’t overthink the legalese going on here because there are a barrage of behaviors that would call for a mistrial in real life. For example, a juror is absolutely not allowed to bring in a piece of evidence like 8 does with the knife. That all has to go through discovery and examination by the lawyers. You also aren’t allowed to threaten to kill fellow jurors or stage elaborate recreations of the trial in the juror box. None of this matters as a true depiction of a juror room would likely be extremely boring. I’m just saying you have to give yourself over to the piece and if you do it’s a very rewarding experience.

My only critiques of the show are with a couple moments that felt a little workman-like when I would have liked to see more build-up and emotion. Like when 8 shows the knife it’s supposed to be a big reveal and it felt a little bit like an afterthought. Also the jurors weren’t always sitting in their order which only matters for someone like myself taking notes but was a little confusing.

Still I highly recommend checking out 12 Angry Jurors at Millcreek Community Theatre. Unfortunately today is the last day to see it but if you can get out there you won’t be disappointed. Next up they have Romeo & Juliet in their show at Canyon Rim Park. For tickets to tonight’s show look here.

12 Angry Jurors is based off of the 1957 film by Reginald Rose which he adapted from the 1954 teleplay of the same name. the play premiered on the West End in 1964 but didn’t show on Broadway until 2004 where it ran for 328 performances

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks like bonus episodes, patron polls and monthly Q&As with actors, directors and writers. Please take a look here.