As much as I enjoy a classic show I also love any chance I get to see something new and original. Such is the opportunity with Pioneer Theatre Company’s latest musical entitled Ten Brave Seconds. It’s a coming of age story that I see a lot of potential in although like anything new there is room for improvement and growth. If this review seems a little stacked on the negative side it’s only in an attempt to be helpful as they are developing the material (and I really do see the potential there.)

Ten Brave Seconds tells the story of a young man in 2015 named Mike who is trying to navigate his coming out experience with his friends and family while also trying to deal with his departed Mother’s birthday. The strength of the show is in the cast who are all strong singers and have a nice believable chemistry together. The standout is Will Blum as the Dad, Carl. His song “Sally at the Park” is probably my favorite of the night as it has a real narrative arc within the song that paints a vivid picture of what the character has been through emotionally. It reminded me of “Soliloquy” from Carousel, the way it told a story through the song.
The show at PTC is directed by Ellie Heyman and she with scenic designer James Noone have made everything flow smoothly with double-sided sets that flip around making the transitions from locker room, to class, to home easy. This keeps the momentum going and the tension building as things get harder for poor Mike.
Speaking of Mike, Carson Stewart brings a warmth and awkwardness the role needs although the music doesn’t give him the stand-out solo I would have liked to see. There is “Citizen” in Act 2 but it was underwhelming for an iconic 11 o’clock number.
While I am sure teens who attend Ten Brave Seconds will feel seen, (especially queer young people that are struggling to come out) it doesn’t feel like the musical has much to add to the coming out conversation that hasn’t already been portrayed so frequently over the last 2 decades. That’s not to say it doesn’t need to be told but the book oddly doesn’t feel very brave in it’s storytelling both with the portrayal of Mike’s struggles and with the responses he receives.

There is also a problem with the conflict feeling redundant. The reaction to his news by his father (who says ‘guess I’m not getting any grandkids’ when told, which seemed like a highly unlikely thing for him to say) and his girlfriend Gabby are very similar. I would encourage them to find a more interesting response for Gabby than betrayal and “but I’m in love with you” (which she probably wouldn’t say at that moment even if that’s how she actually felt.) The teenager discussion should feel different than the parents and yet it really didn’t.
The best scenes in the show occur between Mike and his gay teacher Mr G played by John Cariani. This is partly because it is a distinctly different response than the other 2 main characters but it also felt the most difficult to pin down and a perspective I haven’t seen as often (he’s a realist teacher who is blunt but kind. He also speaks to the evolution of the gay movement and his experience as a gay man vs a modern gay teenager.)
Whether it is fair or not a show like Ten Brave Seconds is almost inevitably going to be compared to Dear Evan Hansen. This is probably especially true for PTC audiences because they just put on a popular production of that musical last Fall. DEH has its issues but it also has some of the best music and lyrics of modern musical theatre, so the comparison is a challenging one. If it were up to me I would make this show stand out more by amplifying the themes of space, the galaxy and Star Trek. This is minimally used in the book and songs and more would help make Mike and Evan’s journeys feel different (the social media component is also a big factor in making DEH work and nothing like that really stands out for Mike’s story.)
All that said, I do see potential here and the earnestness with which Ten Brave Seconds is presented by PTC make it hard to not embrace. It’s definitely worth taking the time to support, and I look forward to seeing how it evolves and grows over the years. If you get to see it I would love to hear what you think (I’d especially love to hear any teenager responses.) It is playing through February 14th and tickets can be purchased here.

Ten Brave Seconds has music and lyrics by Will Van Dyke with book and lyrics by Jeff Talbott. Karen Azenberg is the artistic director of PTC with Adrian Budhu as managing director.
If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks like bonus episodes, patron polls and monthly Q&As with actors, directors and writers. Please take a look here.














