It’s always a tricky thing whenever a play or musical is portraying a marginalized group especially if that group is not the one creating or authoring the production. With their play The Boys Next Door the good folks at PG Players are faced with this challenge in portraying those with mental handicaps and disabilities, and I’d say for the most part they succeed. While not perfect, The Boys Next Door is overall a warm and endearing portrait of an often ignored group without turning them into the inspiration porn we sometimes see.

Set in the 1980s The Boys Next Door tells the story of 4 men with differing mental disabilities that live in a group home in the Boston area. The men are helped by a social worker named Jack (Matthew DelaFuente) who is genuinely friends with the men even if he does become exasperated with them on occasion. For the most part, the first act is a comedy with the men getting into varying shenanigans like accidently flushing the neighbors hamster down the toilet and trying to impress the girls at the local dance.
In Act 2 things get more serious particularly for a character named Barry (Harrison Kaylor) who is the subject of abuse and trauma that is tough to watch. Anxiety-ridden Arnold (Dennis Purdie) is also the victim of bullying at work, a situation that is not really tied up in a bow which I appreciated for its realism.
The biggest issue with The Boys Next Door is one of pacing. This play would be so much better at a good 90 minute runtime but it goes on for 2 1/2 hours. It’s hard to maintain the momentum and not run into caricature with such a long play. It’s like playwright Tom Griffin is asking for trouble. I also didn’t love having Jack speak for the men in long diatribes in-between scenes. These are grown men and we don’t need an able-bodied person to narrate their struggles to us. We see it on the stage.

That said, directors Howard and Kathryn Little have taken imperfect material and put together a meaningful experience. The cast has a nice chemistry together and one can easily tell the performances come from a place of advocacy and compassion. They even have a section of the program ‘Notes from Friends About Living with Neurodiversity and Mental Health Challenges.’ This did not go unnoticed by me and was greatly appreciated.
The acting is all excellent with Purdie giving his 53rd production with PG Players. He has played the role of Arnold before and one can sense his experience and comfort-level with the character. Delafuente is one of the best actors working in amateur theatre in Utah, and he is terrific as Jack even full-on crying at a scene in Act 2. Kaylor is also quite devastating as Barry. You’d never guess in a tiny theater in a library to get this good of performances.
Even with its flaws The Boys Next Door is worthy of your time and certainly the good folks at PG Players are. If you haven’t discovered this gem of Utah County what are you waiting for? It is playing through May 12th and tickets can be purchased here.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks like bonus episodes, patron polls and monthly Q&As with actors, directors and writers. Please take a look here.













