broadway

Utah Theatre Log 11/25-12/14 (She Loves Me, Elf) (Rachel’s Theatre Log 227)

| Rachel's Reviews

Hello theatre lovers. I hope you are having a wonderful December and getting in those wonderful holiday themed shows. Most of what I have seen have been my full detailed reviews as a critic; however, I do have 2 shows I attended as a patron I’d love to catch you all up on. Make sure you are following my instagram for out of show reactions to every show and movie I see (plus other fun content.) I did recently see my 200th show for 2025, which I think is a cool accomplishment for a busy critic like myself. Thanks to all the companies who have let me view their work. It’s something I never take for granted.

She Loves Me- Lehi Arts Council, Lehi

I was thrilled when I found out Lehi Arts Council (one of my favorite arts councils) was putting on She Loves Me for the holidays which is one of my favorite shows. I was even more thrilled when I found out Josh Egbert is playing George because he’s a wonderful local actor. Fortunately the production did not disappoint and it’s one I highly recommend seeing in its final week coming up.

Camilla Curtis plays Amalia and they tell the classic Perfumerie story of 2 coworkers who hate each other in real life but are secretly falling in love over their pen pal letters. While their antics play out on stage we are treated to wonderful songs and a delightful cast including Madison Fitzgerald as Illona and Ed Eyestone as Mr Maraczek (the only time I’ve seen Maraczek with an accent, which is perfect because the musical is supposed to be set in Budapest.) I was particularly impressed with how the cast brought out the humor of the piece making me laugh with their comedic timing and chemistry together. It’s not even a show I think of as particularly funny, but they sold every humorous interaction. Curtis and Egbert have terrific chemistry and they make a couple we are rooting for throughout the story.

She Loves Me at Lehi Arts is directed by Brett Jamison and he makes use of every inch of the tiny space at the center making beds work for multiple scenes or having the store be easy to move around and manipulate into other scenes like the restaurant scene. I loved She Loves Me at BYU last month but this is wonderful as well and well worth your time. It is playing through December 20th and tickets can be purchased here.

Elf: The Musical- Draper Historic Theatre, Draper

Meanwhile over at Draper Historic they are putting on a different fun bubbly holiday musical- Elf. If you have seen the feature film starring Will Farrell than you will enjoy the musical adaptation. It sticks pretty close to the movie with of course songs added in. The songs I think are fairly uninspired but they get the job done I suppose. (If you want to see a fun take on the material check out the underrated stop-motion animated special based on the musical. It’s really nostalgic.)

Anyway, the production in Draper Historic is everything I could want in a community staging of Elf. Director Derrick Cain gets the most out of the tiny stage and large cast. I saw the Twinkle Jingley cast (although it was labeled incorrectly in the program) and while Nathan Krist Janson is a lot of bubbly energy as Buddy (it didn’t feel like an imitation of Farrell which I always appreciate,) the entire Hobbes family stood out the most with Eric Smith as Walter, Katrina Smith as Emily and Sebastian Long as Michael. I particularly liked Katrina Smith and Long in “There is a Santa Claus” in act 2.

They use a lot of projections at this theatre (also designed by Cain) but they do a good job of using them to add to the immersion not as a cheap substitute for practical sets. For example having a screen of Central Park with Santa’s sleigh along with snow coming down and other practical elements adds to the effectiveness of the closing scene or at least doesn’t detract as projections sometimes can do.

I also really enjoyed the costumes by Brooke Holahan and the choreography by Yunnie Kim. Like I said, it’s amazing how much and how many people they get on to the stage in so many scenes. Elf is playing through December 20th at Draper Historic but you’ll have to try standby because it is sold out. The tickets are very affordable and I highly recommend getting a season pass to this wonderful community theater. You can find more information here.

So there you have it 2 quality shows to see this holiday season! Enjoy!

 She Loves Me has music by Jerry Bock and lyrics by Sheldon Harnick with a book by Joe Masteroff. It is based on the Parfumerie play by Miklos Laszlo and first premiered on Broadway in 1963. Elf: The Musical has music by Matthew Sklar and lyrics by Chad Beguelin with a book by Bob Martin and Thomas Meehan based on the 2003 feature film. It first premiered on Broadway in 2010 and had a successful revival in 2024

These logged shows I usually pay for out of pocket, and I’d love to do that as much as possible. If you have a show you’d like me to take a look at and write a full review let me know. I also have my patreon which is a great way to support what I do and get some really fun perks. Find out more here.

‘HADESTOWN: TEEN EDITION’ IS ANOTHER EXCELLENT PRODUCTION FROM LIAHONA THEATRE (REVIEW)

| Rachel's Reviews

It’s always an interesting thing reviewing high school theatre. While I certainly can be constructive my main goal is to be encouraging and help the programs be the best they can for the students. I must be doing something right because I have received a lot of requests from high schools and I’m always honored to do it (I have 3 more coming up in the next few months.) One of the most popular high school shows right now is Hadestown: Teen Edition. Of course, I reviewed the incredible production at Riverton High last fall, have another one coming up soon and there are at least 2 other locally that I did not see that I’m aware of. Today I am taking a look at the Liahona Theatre at the Liahona Preparatory Academy and their production of Hadestown.

Going into this show my expectations were high as Liahona did one of my favorite productions of 2024 with their Starlight Express and now they have another excellent offering with Hadestown. My favorite part is director Jordan Long clearly encourages a lot of students to participate with huge ensemble scenes covering the stage with choreography by Joleah Long. The Workers numbers were particularly impressive with the students looking appropriately robotic and angry. I believe strongly that high school theatre should be cut-free giving everyone the opportunity to be involved and this is certainly the case with productions like this and Starlight Express.

The stage at the Liahona can sometimes be prone to audio and other technical problems so I was very relieved everything went off without any issues. The set by scenic designers Brian and Canon Hadfield is outstanding with a 2-story subway platform with lighting and sound to give the feel of a subway. It was also interesting that the lighting only had the iconic Hadestown mining lights underneath smaller platforms that they used to move the actors around the set. It was very effective especially in the “Road to Hell (Reprise)” to end the show. The costumes by Melody Hadfield particularly on the 3 Fates are beautifully fit and tailored- perfectly designed for each role.

Compared to the Riverton production this cast did feel younger, which can be a little jarring for the darkness of the content but in some cases it added to the characters. In particular Brigham Ker brings a warmth and tenderness to Orpheus I haven’t always seen. He has a very lovely tenor voice and songs like the “Epic” songs he is a real stand-out. Eurydice, on the other hand, played by Amera Davis can really nail those low notes in songs like “Flowers.” The other leads are all terrific teen performers.

There’s still one more chance to support these wonderful teens in their production of Hadestown: Teen Edition. I think you will definitely find it worthy of your time. You can purchase tickets here.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.

‘DRAG: THE MUSICAL’ IS A CAMPY GOOD TIME BUT ALSO SURPRISINGLY SWEET (OFF BROADWAY REVIEW)

| Rachel's Reviews

As a film and theatre critic I think it is valuable to push myself out of my comfort zone. While it is good for longevity to find a niche and specialize in content as I have done with romantic comedies and holiday material I want to continually grow and expand my tastes each day. This is why when given the opportunity to see Drag: The Musical during my last New York trip I jumped at the chance. In many ways I am not the target demographic for this show but I think an outsider perspective can often have value and be informative to my readers who may be interested in seeing the play or film but also in allowing their vision of me as a human and critic to not be so narrow and limited. Anyway, I was given the opportunity to see Drag: The Musical at the New World Stages, an Off Broadway theatre and I left having had a good time with a surprisingly sweet and endearing production.

My main context for saying I am not the target demographic for this show is I am basically unfamiliar with the drag movement and the fandom associated with show’s like RuPaul’s Drag Race. I am not morally opposed to it it’s just not something I have watched or become informed on. Those that are familiar with the scene will find much to be excited for in the cast and story of Drag: The Musical. The audience cheered when certain performers appeared so I only assume they have a following and will be enjoyable for their fans to see perform live.

The story (the book, music, and lyrics were all collaboratively written by Tomas Costanza, Justin Andrew Honard, and Ashley Gordon) is basic but it does the job to provide setpieces for the queens to sing, dance and even give some heart that I didn’t expect from a campy show like this. The setup is Kitty Galloway (Alaska Thunderfuck) and Alexis Gillmore (Nick Adams) are feuding exes who run opposing clubs near each other. Unbeknownst to both they are both facing financial struggles and Alexis’ straight brother Tom comes in to help the Fish Tank from going under (Kitty runs the fancier but equally struggling Cat House.)

When I saw it Tom was played by Joey McIntyre, which as an 80s girl was a lot of fun to see. The entire cast had a nice chemistry together even when they were supposed to be feuding with each other. J. Elaine Marcos delivers the lion-share of the laughs playing 3 roles- an IRS agent, a sleezy lawyer, and a difficult landlady. Eddie Korbich plays a character known as Drunk Jerry that was less effective in delivering the laughs but his character is a bridge between both clubs the story relies upon.

Director Spencer Liff keeps the action moving from gag to sentimental moment; however, I do think the show is long for not having an intermission and my friend had to leave midway through to use the bathroom and then struggled to find her seat again. In addition, while I found it to be amusing I wasn’t uproariously laughing like I was for another show I saw at New World Stages as a patron Dracula: A Comedy of Terrors or for The Play that Goes Wrong which is still playing there (although I haven’t seen it there but other places.) Surprisingly I almost find it to be a more satisfying piece of good-natured sentimentality than a laugh-out-loud comedy. At its core Drag: The Musical is about family and of course love and acceptance, which is always a message worthy of sharing.

The production elements of the show are definitely worthy of praise. Jason Sherwood’s set manages to tell the stories of both clubs while giving plenty of space for laughs to occur. The costumes by Marco Marco are as big and over-the-top as fans will hope for and the lighting by Adam Honoré is perfect in capturing that club atmosphere needed for the story.

Both Alaska and Adams are a lot of fun in their roles with Alaska getting the more dishy of the leads but particularly Adams’ interactions with young Yair Keydar playing nephew Brendan are very warm and endearing. Like I said, I think many will be surprised how sweet and family-oriented a show like Drag: the Musical is. It’s certainly not what I was expecting.

If you are in the fandom I definitely recommend finding your way to New World Stages and seeing Drag: The Musical and even if you’re not give it a shot. It just might surprise you! Adam Pascal is now playing the role of Tom, which would be a lot of fun to see. You can find more information and get tickets here.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.

‘A WONDERFUL WORLD’ SHOULD BE MORE WONDERFUL (BROADWAY REVIEW)

| Rachel's Reviews

One of the frustrating parts about writing criticism of any kind is most people want a binary praise or pan from critics when the truth is usually somewhere in between. With theatre criticism, for example, I rarely see something I outright hate and wish I hadn’t seen. That said, with the high prices of tickets and the many demands on people’s time I can say when something did not entertain me enough to be worth a recommendation. Such is the case with A Wonderful World: The Louis Armstrong Musical, a new musical on Broadway about the famed jazz musician Louis Armstrong. While this musical has much to admire it sinks under the weight of an overlong and dull book that makes Armstrong feel more generic than wonderful.

I saw A Wonderful World on a Thursday but James T Lane was playing the role of Armstrong instead of James Monroe Iglehart. According to the program Lane is the alternate on Tuesday and Fridays but my week must have been an exception; nevertheless, there’s a good chance you might see Lane if you purchase a ticket. While I haven’t seen Iglehart I do think Lane looks a little bit more like Armstrong and he perfectly captures the gravely tone of voice required for the role so I didn’t feel at all cheated not getting Iglehart.

There are also some really strong moments in the musical. The 2 acts are divided into 4 sections by book writer Aurin Squire and each of these segments are narrated and focus on Armstrong’s 4 wives. We also get to know various performers and mob bosses he worked with like King Joe Oliver played by Gavin Gregory. The wives approach is an interesting one because it makes the show feel a little cyclical as there isn’t enough of a difference between each relationship and their rise and fall largely follow the same pattern. The biggest standout is Darlesia Cearcy playing the final wife Lucille as she gets a booming number “That’s My Home.”

The production at Studio 54 is worthy of praise. Direction by Christopher Renshaw is doing what he can with the material with a set by Adam Koch and Steven Royal that has to be able to transform between many different eras and locations quickly. The orchestrations by Branford Marsalis and choreography by Rickey Tripp are also excellent.

If audiences are unfamiliar with the type of jukebox biographical musical A Wonderful World is aping they might find the show more palatable but at nearly 3 hours the predictable beats and repetitive story arcs grow tiresome. I’m not sure how they could cut out one or more of the wives, but it’s a show that could easily be 30 minutes shorter and be better off for it. If you are a huge Armstrong fan and want to learn more about his life than maybe this show will be of interest but if not it unfortunately ends up feeling like more of a slog than a stunner.

If you are interested in learning more about A Wonderful World: The Louis Armstrong Musical check out here.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.

‘KIMBERLY AKIMBO’ NATIONAL TOUR IS NOT THE GREAT ADVENTURE I HOPED FOR (REVIEW)

| Rachel's Reviews

One of the interesting experiences of being a film and theatre critic is occasionally having unpopular opinions. From time-to-time something that is widely praised will not work for me and I hope I have the ability to explain my difference of opinion as competently as possible. Some people, however, will always feel threatened by this difference of opinion and that’s just a reality every critic has to deal with. I say all this because I definitely had an unpopular opinion after seeing Tony Award winning musical Kimberly Akimbo and I hope I can explain why I left feeling underwhelmed rather than charmed and moved as I was hoping for.

Let’s start with some strengths. First of all the premise is endearing and heartfelt. We have the lead Kimberly who has progeria that makes her age rapidly so at 16 she has the appearance of a 60 year old woman. This causes her to not only grapple with her own mortality (she has already lived longer than doctors predicted) but have a different appearance than her peers. I also appreciate how raw and authentic the characters are with everyone who surrounds Kimberly being flawed human beings who make messy choices. This adds a degree of unpredictability to a story that could otherwise veer into maudlin sentimentality. The book by David Lindsay-Abaire can also be quite funny and insightful.

Unfortunately the problems with Kimberly Akimbo take away from the strengths making for an uneven viewing experience. My biggest issue was the songs with lyrics by Lindsay-Abaire and music by Jeanine Tesori. Before being released as a musical Lindsay-Abaire released this story as a play and I’d be very curious to see that if I ever got the chance. I bet I would enjoy it more. Almost across the board the songs felt generic and lifeless. Honestly this wasn’t completely surprising as I hadn’t been impressed by the original cast recording but with all the praise I assumed it’s one of those shows you just have to see live to get. Not so much. The only song that I would independently listen to is “Great Adventure” and this is a problem because its the last song of the show!

The other problem is the moral murkiness of the characters, while appealing in some ways it can create tonal whiplash especially when we consider most of the characters are teenagers. While I enjoyed Aunt Debra (Emily Koch) it does strain credulity that she would involve teenagers in her check cashing scheme. Teenagers who are both extremely unreliable and would receive little of the blame if the plan came to light, which it almost certainly would. I think the narrative wants us to root for Debra as an anti-hero but it’s pretty hard when she is being so thoughtless and unkind.

I am sure Victoria Clark (who I have seen on Broadway in The Light in the Piazza) was incredible as Kimberly but Carolee Carmelo didn’t quite do it for me in the role for the national tour. Even her voice and mannerisms felt like a caricature of a teenager rather than an authentic young person who happens to have an old body.

Everything else in the production was fine. The direction by Jessica Stone gets the job done and the scenic design by David Zinn feels appropriately midwest. The most impressive section of direction was the way the “Skater Planet” scenes felt like actual ice skating. I also enjoyed the video projections by Lucy Mackinnon particularly in the finale when we get to see the “Great Adventure” Kimberly and Seth (Miguel Gil) go on.

Perhaps if one can go into Kimberly Akimbo with more moderate expectations one can appreciate the risks it takes and the heartfelt message it is trying to convey but even with those good aspects I can’t recommend it. The lead performance didn’t work, the tone is all over the place and most importantly the songs are uninspired. I hope my readers enjoy it more than I did but it’s a definite ‘not for me.’

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.

‘ELF: THE MUSICAL’ WILL MAKE YOU HAPPY ALL THE TIME THIS HOLIDAY SEASON (REVIEW)

| Rachel's Reviews

One of the most enjoyable aspects of the holiday season on Broadway is the limited run festive productions we get to see to add some Christmas cheer to our theatre-going lives. This year’s entry (make sure you check out my thoughts on the annual Rockettes Spectacular here) is the revival of Elf: The Musical at the Marriott Marquis on Broadway. It’s a high energy comedy the whole family will enjoy and a great way to get some holiday cheer if you’re feeling a little blue.

Elf: The Musical is based on the popular 2003 film starring Will Farrell about a human who is raised as an elf who comes to New York City to find his long-lost (naughty listed) father Walter. I love fish-out-of-water comedies and Elf works as a film because the innocent and sweet antics of Buddy are in such contrast to the cynicism of New York and particular business world New York. Bob Martin and Thomas Meehan have captured this energy in their book adaptation and created something that makes it hard to not find endearing.

There are some mild changes from the film such as Buddy doesn’t have an elf father figure outside of Santa and the incredible author is talked about rather than seen (he’s played by Peter Dinklage in the movie.) However, most of the funny lines are kept from the film and certainly the overall tone and appeal of the character remain in tact.

At the Marquis revival Buddy is played by Grey Henson with the child-like energy you want for the character. Michael Hayden is appropriately gruff as his dad Walter and Ashley Brown and Kai Edgar steal the show as his new stepmom and stepbrother (one of my favorite musical moments is their song “There is a Santa Claus.) The big star performance comes with Sean Astin as Santa Claus and the boss Mr Greenway. Since Santa is off-stage for most of the production it makes sense to use the cast as much as possible and he is a lot of fun in both roles. One can easily see he’s having a great time with the production and that positive energy is what is needed for a show like this.

My favorite number of this production of Elf: the Musical is when the beleaguered mall Santas sing “Nobody Cares About Santa.” The choreography by Liam Steel in this song is charming and it’s a catchy tune by Matthew Sklar (music) and Chad Beguelin (lyrics.) This is also one of my favorite set designs of the night with the Santas eating at a Chinese restaurant, which is of course open on Christmas Eve.

Speaking of the songs most of the other songs by Sklar and Beguelin are fine but on the generic side. Like most Broadway shows it could definitely use a good trim as songs like “I’ll Believe in You” and “A Christmas Song” are pretty basic. Director Philip Wm. McKinley has also not done anything to make the production stand out as far as staging or setpieces. It’s all fine but I’ve seen local productions (one here at Hale Center Theatre Sandy last year) with more sumptuous sets and a more magical North Pole presence (when you think about it should the Chinese restaurant set be the most impressive part of this show?) It was, however, interesting to see what a difference the live orchestra makes as I’ve only seen it with a pre-recorded track.

Nevertheless, if a festive family offering is what you are looking for this holiday season Elf: The Musical at the Marriott Marquis will more than satisfy. It’s positive and hopeful with lots of good laughs for all to enjoy. If near Broadway this Christmas I say give “The Story of Buddy the Elf” a try. It is playing through January 4th and tickets can be purchased here.

Also if you’ve never seen it I recommend the stop motion film they made off the musical a few years ago. It’s very charming. You can purchase it here (ad)

PS. This is the first time I’ve ever reviewed a musical on Broadway as a critic. Very surreal and exciting for me. Thanks for the opportunity!

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.

RACHEL’S THEATRE LOG 77 (NYC TRIP 1- ROCKETTES SPECTACULAR, DEATH BECOMES HER)

| Rachel's Reviews

Hi theatre friends! Last week I was able to make my way to the great NYC for a little post-Thanksgiving trip with my family. It was actually a really fun experience because my aunts and cousins were as well as 2 of my sisters all enjoying New York and remembering my Grandma Wagner who we all miss so much. I also got to see some Broadway shows while I was there and that included 2 I paid for and 3 are comped; therefore, they will get their own full reviews coming soon. However, today I am going to share quick thoughts on the 2 I paid for and attended as patrons.

RADIO CITY CHRISTMAS SPECTACULAR-

One of the key memories of my Grandma when it comes to New York is seeing the Rockettes in all their holiday glory. They are in fact a spectacular in every way in the Radio City Christmas Spectacular! I saw this production years ago with my Grandma in 2000 but haven’t seen it since but they’ve definitely updated elements over the years. The most stunning feature was the projections that went out onto the ceiling and into the audience. They even had a sequence with Santas where the projections are shadows of the Santas (or we think so at first) and then the shadows start dancing independent of the Santas. It’s very clever.

Of course the Rockettes are amazing in this production. The kicklines and other choreography never fail to impress along with when the wooden soldiers drop on top of each other in a line together. They also had new innovations like the snow fairies as little drones with wings which is fun to see.

The highlight of the performance was the live nativity with farm animals (and even camels!) They truly do have all the Christmas one could ever absorb and I recommend checking it out. The Spectacular is playing through Jan 5th and you can find out more here.

DEATH BECOMES HER

Next up we have the new musical Death Becomes Her. This, of course, is based on the classic film from from 1992 and has music and lyrics by Julia Mattison and Noel Carey with a book by Marco Pennette. It tells the story of 2 feuding divas who end up taking a beauty potion that has grisly consequences even after they have technically died.

The main standout for this show is the very funny script and the wonderful leading performances of Megan Hilty as Madeline and Jennifer Simard as Helen. I was unfamiliar with Simard (although I think I had seen her in the recent revival of Company) but she particularly steals the show with her incredibly funny and physical performance. Michelle Williams is also excellent as the mysterious Viola Van Horn who provides the beauty potion. My only regret is the script doesn’t give any time for the 3 of them to be on stage together or have a song with each other.

Director Christopher Gattelli keeps everything popping on stage with dazzling special effects as things get more and more unhinged for our partly-dead ladies. I won’t spoil it for you but there’s even one visual effect involving a severed head that I’m still not entirely sure how they pulled it off. The songs are catchy with bangers like “If You Want Perfection” and “For the Gaze” and the costumes by Paul Tazewell are as big and unforgettable as you’d hope for.

After I left the theatre I said Death Becomes Her is the best comedy I’ve seen on Broadway since The Drowsy Chaperone back in 2006 and it is certainly one of the best screen to stage adaptations we’ve ever had. I really enjoyed it and hope it has a long life on Broadway. You can purchase tickets to it here.

I will have individual reviews of the 3 other shows I saw as they were the comped tickets but let me know if you have seen the Rockettes or Death Becomes Her and what you thought of it.

These logged shows I pay for out of pocket and I’d love to do that as much as possible. If you have a show you’d like to take a look at and write a full review let me know. I also have my patreon which is a great way to support what I do and get some really fun perks. Find out more here.

RIVERTON HIGH SCHOOLERS STUN IN HADESTOWN: TEEN EDITION (REVIEW)

| Rachel's Reviews

When I first saw Hadestown in 2022 on Broadway I honestly walked away with mixed feelings. While most of my friends seemed ready to declare it the next musical masterpiece I felt it was more style over substance. Therefore, I was excited to give the material another chance- this time in the Teen Edition at Riverton High School. Now having seen it I still have some of the story issues but I was blown away by what the teens did and everyone involved should be commended.

Hadestown is the creation of (book, lyrics and music) Anais Mitchell based on the Greek myth Orpheus and Eurydice. It tells the story of Orpheus who goes into the underworld to try and save his love. Along the way we have all kinds of characters like Hades, Persephone and Hermes.

One of my friends who is a Hadestown superfan expressed concerns about it being appropriate for a teen edition but he needn’t be. The team have done an excellent job making it appropriate for older teens and it’s a perfect show for high schoolers to do because it has huge ensemble scenes which allow for many young people to get their first taste in theater. At Riverton director Erin McGuire has taken this strong adaptation and seemingly thought of everything to make a winning production.

On Broadway so much of the appeal of Hadestown is the incredible production values which made it interesting to see a more stripped down version at Riverton. The set is simple but the lights and steampunk elements (including industrial projections on the side walls) make for an immersive experience. Everything went off seemingly without a hitch from the trap doors to the lighting, to the fog elements. I especially loved when the large cast (over 80 kids) comes out into the aisles with their lights and movement. They also didn’t have any major sound issues which is usually a problem at high school productions.

The cast is also excellent with teens taking on these challenging roles loaded with exposition, dance, complex emotions and more. The highlight was Ethan Hull as Hades. His deep bass voice is incredible in songs like “Hey Little Shepherd. He should absolutely apply for the Jimmy Awards. I think he’d be a shoe-in. Emma Tyson was also strong as Persephone in songs like “Living it Up on Top” and “Why We Build the Wall.”

The music is also a standout of the show at Riverton with an on stage band of 7 musicians, some of them professional adults. Especially for a show like Hadestown we need the gritty grounded reality of live musicians as opposed to a prerecorded track. It makes all the difference in the world.

If you haven’t seen Hadestown I thoroughly recommend checking out Riverton High’s production. It may be a teen edition but it’s also an incredible edition! It is playing for one more day tomorrow and I highly recommend it. You can purchase tickets here.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.

‘PETER PAN’ NATIONAL TOUR IS SURPRISINGLY MAGICAL (REVIEW)

| Rachel's Reviews

Of all the classic stories of childhood I have never been that drawn to the story of Peter Pan. Whether film or theatre I would way rather watch something on The Wizard of Oz or Alice in Wonderland and certainly Cinderella than Peter Pan. With this background when I saw the national tour of Peter Pan was coming to Eccles I wasn’t very excited. Nevertheless I always try and go into any play or musical with an open mind and it’s a good thing I did. To my surprise I thoroughly enjoyed this production and hope people will give it a chance as it comes to a city near you.

Peter Pan is of course based on the classic play by J.M Barrie (1904). Music was added in 1954 and it has had many film and television adaptations including the iconic 1953 animated Disney film. In general the songs in the animated film are better, although at times more problematic, than this musical but they both have their entertaining moments and capture the escapism of Neverland. My favorite version of Peter Pan is actually the 2003 version starring Jeremy Sumpter and Jason Isaacs but most of them have their fans.

The most successful aspects of this production land where it embraces both spectacle and tradition. Most companies are using a lot of video projections these days often with AI-inspired or created graphics. This can create a plasticy and cheap looking effects but this production used the projections beautifully. Particularly in the flying sequences the projection work by designer David Bengali took my breath away. I also appreciate the nearly gratuitous glitter usage to add to magic of the flying effects. The flying was just incredible (Did I mention I liked the flying?)

The direction by Lonny Price in general is super impressive. I couldn’t believe how quickly they made scene changes and maneuvered their large cast around. The cast is also wonderful in their roles especially Cody Garcia as Hook/Mr Darling (although his accent did wander throughout the night.) He nailed the comedy of the character and that’s what’s most important. I also enjoyed Nolan Almeida as Peter and find it refreshing they went with a young man over the traditional middle-aged female casting to the character. It was a little strange to have Hawa Kamara as Wendy when she is clearly an adult and John and Michael are  children but I got used to it fairly quickly and her singing is lovely.

My main quibble with the production is the needless attempts to modernize the script. It’s frankly lazy and groan-inducing when we hear references to viral videos and social media in our Peter Pan retelling. I also see no reason to get rid of Nanny the dog in favor of a gen-z babysitter. It’s also not more empowering for Wendy to be super into medicine and want to become a doctor as opposed to being a mother (the Disney version we get a whole song about her being a mother which I love.) Stuff like that takes me out of the moment and is distracting when stories like Peter Pan should be timeless.

That said, I still really enjoyed the national tour of Peter Pan. It is the perfect combination of magic and big-hearted storytelling. If it is coming to a city near you I’d definitely check it out. It would be a great way to introduce kids to their first Broadway musical. Peter Pan is playing at the Eccles until 11/10 and you can purchase tickets here.

Peter Pan has music by Jule Styne, Mark Charlap, and Trude Rittmann with lyrics by Betty Comden, Adolph Green and Carolyn Leigh. Based on the book by J.M. Barrie.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.