elf

Utah Theatre Log 11/25-12/14 (She Loves Me, Elf) (Rachel’s Theatre Log 227)

| Rachel's Reviews

Hello theatre lovers. I hope you are having a wonderful December and getting in those wonderful holiday themed shows. Most of what I have seen have been my full detailed reviews as a critic; however, I do have 2 shows I attended as a patron I’d love to catch you all up on. Make sure you are following my instagram for out of show reactions to every show and movie I see (plus other fun content.) I did recently see my 200th show for 2025, which I think is a cool accomplishment for a busy critic like myself. Thanks to all the companies who have let me view their work. It’s something I never take for granted.

She Loves Me- Lehi Arts Council, Lehi

I was thrilled when I found out Lehi Arts Council (one of my favorite arts councils) was putting on She Loves Me for the holidays which is one of my favorite shows. I was even more thrilled when I found out Josh Egbert is playing George because he’s a wonderful local actor. Fortunately the production did not disappoint and it’s one I highly recommend seeing in its final week coming up.

Camilla Curtis plays Amalia and they tell the classic Perfumerie story of 2 coworkers who hate each other in real life but are secretly falling in love over their pen pal letters. While their antics play out on stage we are treated to wonderful songs and a delightful cast including Madison Fitzgerald as Illona and Ed Eyestone as Mr Maraczek (the only time I’ve seen Maraczek with an accent, which is perfect because the musical is supposed to be set in Budapest.) I was particularly impressed with how the cast brought out the humor of the piece making me laugh with their comedic timing and chemistry together. It’s not even a show I think of as particularly funny, but they sold every humorous interaction. Curtis and Egbert have terrific chemistry and they make a couple we are rooting for throughout the story.

She Loves Me at Lehi Arts is directed by Brett Jamison and he makes use of every inch of the tiny space at the center making beds work for multiple scenes or having the store be easy to move around and manipulate into other scenes like the restaurant scene. I loved She Loves Me at BYU last month but this is wonderful as well and well worth your time. It is playing through December 20th and tickets can be purchased here.

Elf: The Musical- Draper Historic Theatre, Draper

Meanwhile over at Draper Historic they are putting on a different fun bubbly holiday musical- Elf. If you have seen the feature film starring Will Farrell than you will enjoy the musical adaptation. It sticks pretty close to the movie with of course songs added in. The songs I think are fairly uninspired but they get the job done I suppose. (If you want to see a fun take on the material check out the underrated stop-motion animated special based on the musical. It’s really nostalgic.)

Anyway, the production in Draper Historic is everything I could want in a community staging of Elf. Director Derrick Cain gets the most out of the tiny stage and large cast. I saw the Twinkle Jingley cast (although it was labeled incorrectly in the program) and while Nathan Krist Janson is a lot of bubbly energy as Buddy (it didn’t feel like an imitation of Farrell which I always appreciate,) the entire Hobbes family stood out the most with Eric Smith as Walter, Katrina Smith as Emily and Sebastian Long as Michael. I particularly liked Katrina Smith and Long in “There is a Santa Claus” in act 2.

They use a lot of projections at this theatre (also designed by Cain) but they do a good job of using them to add to the immersion not as a cheap substitute for practical sets. For example having a screen of Central Park with Santa’s sleigh along with snow coming down and other practical elements adds to the effectiveness of the closing scene or at least doesn’t detract as projections sometimes can do.

I also really enjoyed the costumes by Brooke Holahan and the choreography by Yunnie Kim. Like I said, it’s amazing how much and how many people they get on to the stage in so many scenes. Elf is playing through December 20th at Draper Historic but you’ll have to try standby because it is sold out. The tickets are very affordable and I highly recommend getting a season pass to this wonderful community theater. You can find more information here.

So there you have it 2 quality shows to see this holiday season! Enjoy!

 She Loves Me has music by Jerry Bock and lyrics by Sheldon Harnick with a book by Joe Masteroff. It is based on the Parfumerie play by Miklos Laszlo and first premiered on Broadway in 1963. Elf: The Musical has music by Matthew Sklar and lyrics by Chad Beguelin with a book by Bob Martin and Thomas Meehan based on the 2003 feature film. It first premiered on Broadway in 2010 and had a successful revival in 2024

These logged shows I usually pay for out of pocket, and I’d love to do that as much as possible. If you have a show you’d like me to take a look at and write a full review let me know. I also have my patreon which is a great way to support what I do and get some really fun perks. Find out more here.

‘ELF: THE MUSICAL’ WILL MAKE YOU HAPPY ALL THE TIME THIS HOLIDAY SEASON (REVIEW)

| Rachel's Reviews

One of the most enjoyable aspects of the holiday season on Broadway is the limited run festive productions we get to see to add some Christmas cheer to our theatre-going lives. This year’s entry (make sure you check out my thoughts on the annual Rockettes Spectacular here) is the revival of Elf: The Musical at the Marriott Marquis on Broadway. It’s a high energy comedy the whole family will enjoy and a great way to get some holiday cheer if you’re feeling a little blue.

Elf: The Musical is based on the popular 2003 film starring Will Farrell about a human who is raised as an elf who comes to New York City to find his long-lost (naughty listed) father Walter. I love fish-out-of-water comedies and Elf works as a film because the innocent and sweet antics of Buddy are in such contrast to the cynicism of New York and particular business world New York. Bob Martin and Thomas Meehan have captured this energy in their book adaptation and created something that makes it hard to not find endearing.

There are some mild changes from the film such as Buddy doesn’t have an elf father figure outside of Santa and the incredible author is talked about rather than seen (he’s played by Peter Dinklage in the movie.) However, most of the funny lines are kept from the film and certainly the overall tone and appeal of the character remain in tact.

At the Marquis revival Buddy is played by Grey Henson with the child-like energy you want for the character. Michael Hayden is appropriately gruff as his dad Walter and Ashley Brown and Kai Edgar steal the show as his new stepmom and stepbrother (one of my favorite musical moments is their song “There is a Santa Claus.) The big star performance comes with Sean Astin as Santa Claus and the boss Mr Greenway. Since Santa is off-stage for most of the production it makes sense to use the cast as much as possible and he is a lot of fun in both roles. One can easily see he’s having a great time with the production and that positive energy is what is needed for a show like this.

My favorite number of this production of Elf: the Musical is when the beleaguered mall Santas sing “Nobody Cares About Santa.” The choreography by Liam Steel in this song is charming and it’s a catchy tune by Matthew Sklar (music) and Chad Beguelin (lyrics.) This is also one of my favorite set designs of the night with the Santas eating at a Chinese restaurant, which is of course open on Christmas Eve.

Speaking of the songs most of the other songs by Sklar and Beguelin are fine but on the generic side. Like most Broadway shows it could definitely use a good trim as songs like “I’ll Believe in You” and “A Christmas Song” are pretty basic. Director Philip Wm. McKinley has also not done anything to make the production stand out as far as staging or setpieces. It’s all fine but I’ve seen local productions (one here at Hale Center Theatre Sandy last year) with more sumptuous sets and a more magical North Pole presence (when you think about it should the Chinese restaurant set be the most impressive part of this show?) It was, however, interesting to see what a difference the live orchestra makes as I’ve only seen it with a pre-recorded track.

Nevertheless, if a festive family offering is what you are looking for this holiday season Elf: The Musical at the Marriott Marquis will more than satisfy. It’s positive and hopeful with lots of good laughs for all to enjoy. If near Broadway this Christmas I say give “The Story of Buddy the Elf” a try. It is playing through January 4th and tickets can be purchased here.

Also if you’ve never seen it I recommend the stop motion film they made off the musical a few years ago. It’s very charming. You can purchase it here (ad)

PS. This is the first time I’ve ever reviewed a musical on Broadway as a critic. Very surreal and exciting for me. Thanks for the opportunity!

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.