One of the frustrating parts about writing criticism of any kind is most people want a binary praise or pan from critics when the truth is usually somewhere in between. With theatre criticism, for example, I rarely see something I outright hate and wish I hadn’t seen. That said, with the high prices of tickets and the many demands on people’s time I can say when something did not entertain me enough to be worth a recommendation. Such is the case with A Wonderful World: The Louis Armstrong Musical, a new musical on Broadway about the famed jazz musician Louis Armstrong. While this musical has much to admire it sinks under the weight of an overlong and dull book that makes Armstrong feel more generic than wonderful.

I saw A Wonderful World on a Thursday but James T Lane was playing the role of Armstrong instead of James Monroe Iglehart. According to the program Lane is the alternate on Tuesday and Fridays but my week must have been an exception; nevertheless, there’s a good chance you might see Lane if you purchase a ticket. While I haven’t seen Iglehart I do think Lane looks a little bit more like Armstrong and he perfectly captures the gravely tone of voice required for the role so I didn’t feel at all cheated not getting Iglehart.

There are also some really strong moments in the musical. The 2 acts are divided into 4 sections by book writer Aurin Squire and each of these segments are narrated and focus on Armstrong’s 4 wives. We also get to know various performers and mob bosses he worked with like King Joe Oliver played by Gavin Gregory. The wives approach is an interesting one because it makes the show feel a little cyclical as there isn’t enough of a difference between each relationship and their rise and fall largely follow the same pattern. The biggest standout is Darlesia Cearcy playing the final wife Lucille as she gets a booming number “That’s My Home.”

The production at Studio 54 is worthy of praise. Direction by Christopher Renshaw is doing what he can with the material with a set by Adam Koch and Steven Royal that has to be able to transform between many different eras and locations quickly. The orchestrations by Branford Marsalis and choreography by Rickey Tripp are also excellent.

If audiences are unfamiliar with the type of jukebox biographical musical A Wonderful World is aping they might find the show more palatable but at nearly 3 hours the predictable beats and repetitive story arcs grow tiresome. I’m not sure how they could cut out one or more of the wives, but it’s a show that could easily be 30 minutes shorter and be better off for it. If you are a huge Armstrong fan and want to learn more about his life than maybe this show will be of interest but if not it unfortunately ends up feeling like more of a slog than a stunner.

If you are interested in learning more about A Wonderful World: The Louis Armstrong Musical check out here.

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.