One of the interesting experiences of being a film and theatre critic is occasionally having unpopular opinions. From time-to-time something that is widely praised will not work for me and I hope I have the ability to explain my difference of opinion as competently as possible. Some people, however, will always feel threatened by this difference of opinion and that’s just a reality every critic has to deal with. I say all this because I definitely had an unpopular opinion after seeing Tony Award winning musical Kimberly Akimbo and I hope I can explain why I left feeling underwhelmed rather than charmed and moved as I was hoping for.

Let’s start with some strengths. First of all the premise is endearing and heartfelt. We have the lead Kimberly who has progeria that makes her age rapidly so at 16 she has the appearance of a 60 year old woman. This causes her to not only grapple with her own mortality (she has already lived longer than doctors predicted) but have a different appearance than her peers. I also appreciate how raw and authentic the characters are with everyone who surrounds Kimberly being flawed human beings who make messy choices. This adds a degree of unpredictability to a story that could otherwise veer into maudlin sentimentality. The book by David Lindsay-Abaire can also be quite funny and insightful.

Unfortunately the problems with Kimberly Akimbo take away from the strengths making for an uneven viewing experience. My biggest issue was the songs with lyrics by Lindsay-Abaire and music by Jeanine Tesori. Before being released as a musical Lindsay-Abaire released this story as a play and I’d be very curious to see that if I ever got the chance. I bet I would enjoy it more. Almost across the board the songs felt generic and lifeless. Honestly this wasn’t completely surprising as I hadn’t been impressed by the original cast recording but with all the praise I assumed it’s one of those shows you just have to see live to get. Not so much. The only song that I would independently listen to is “Great Adventure” and this is a problem because its the last song of the show!

The other problem is the moral murkiness of the characters, while appealing in some ways it can create tonal whiplash especially when we consider most of the characters are teenagers. While I enjoyed Aunt Debra (Emily Koch) it does strain credulity that she would involve teenagers in her check cashing scheme. Teenagers who are both extremely unreliable and would receive little of the blame if the plan came to light, which it almost certainly would. I think the narrative wants us to root for Debra as an anti-hero but it’s pretty hard when she is being so thoughtless and unkind.

I am sure Victoria Clark (who I have seen on Broadway in The Light in the Piazza) was incredible as Kimberly but Carolee Carmelo didn’t quite do it for me in the role for the national tour. Even her voice and mannerisms felt like a caricature of a teenager rather than an authentic young person who happens to have an old body.

Everything else in the production was fine. The direction by Jessica Stone gets the job done and the scenic design by David Zinn feels appropriately midwest. The most impressive section of direction was the way the “Skater Planet” scenes felt like actual ice skating. I also enjoyed the video projections by Lucy Mackinnon particularly in the finale when we get to see the “Great Adventure” Kimberly and Seth (Miguel Gil) go on.

Perhaps if one can go into Kimberly Akimbo with more moderate expectations one can appreciate the risks it takes and the heartfelt message it is trying to convey but even with those good aspects I can’t recommend it. The lead performance didn’t work, the tone is all over the place and most importantly the songs are uninspired. I hope my readers enjoy it more than I did but it’s a definite ‘not for me.’

If you enjoy my writing and would like me to review your production I’d love to. I also have a patreon which is a great way to support my shorter logs for shows I don’t get to review. I have some really fun perks. Please take a look here.